The Chinese study claiming that Covid originated in India was withdrawn

NEW DELHI: A study that claimed the Indian subcontinent may be the site of the earliest human-to-human transmission of coronavirus has been withdrawn from the prepress platform of The Lancet, the Global Times recently reported. .
The Global Times said the study was first posted on, the prepress platform of The Lancet, on November 17, but the article was withdrawn.
Staff at the Institute of Neuroscience at the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS) also confirmed to the Global Times that the study had been withdrawn from the platform.
The study was conducted by researchers at the Institute of Neuroscience at CAS, Fudan University in Shanghai and Texas University in Houston.
The pre-printed study, entitled “Early Cryptic Transmission and the Evolution of SARS-CoV-2 in Human Hosts,” suggested that the Indian subcontinent may be the site of the earliest human-to-human transmission of coronavirus, three or four. . a few months before the outbreak in Wuhan.
The Global Times said that withdrawing a study from SSRN.Com is not a surprise. “Should researchers or the research institute find that their studies may not have data or may not be solid or deliberate enough to draw a conclusion, they would consider withdrawing the study,” a Global Times official said. Beijing public health expert on condition of anonymity, “the report told the Global Times.
He said that “the withdrawal of this study on the origin of the virus shows that tracking the origin of the virus worldwide is a complicated scientific question, which is not an easy task and is far from reaching a conclusion without international cooperation.”
As the paper was still a pre-printed version that has not yet gone through the peer review process, the withdrawal could mean that the results of the study may require further verification, experts said.
“Several pieces of evidence suggest the early existence of the virus in the world before humans became aware of it and indicate several sources,” he added.
The Global Times said a study by the National Cancer Institute in Milan found the new coronavirus in blood samples collected in October 2019, and research conducted by the University of Barcelona showed the presence of the virus in sewage samples in Barcelona in March 2019.
On Monday, the Wall Street Journal also cited a government study that said Covid-19 was likely in the U.S. in mid-December, about a month before the country reported its first case and a few weeks before China report his first case.
Francois Balloux, director of the UCL Institute of Genetics and professor of computational systems biology at University College London, described the work of Chinese researchers as “nonsense.” “A piece of nonsense, arguing # SARSCoV2, is from India, sent to the Lancet. I can only hope that the ‘peer review’ process will remove it promptly.”